This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
Enjoy this delicious Peanut Butter Fudge! Smooth and creamy, sweet and marshmallowy, this fudge is a delicious holiday treat great for gifting, sharing, and shipping to your loved ones.
Peanut Butter Fudge is the most requested candy I’ve ever made.
Men, in particular, love it.ย Maybe it’s the peanut butter, maybe it’s because it’s so sweet and creamy! ย I created this recipe by adapting the original chocolate Fantasy Fudge RECIPE on the back of the Jet-puffed Marshmallow Cream jar many, many years ago. Everybody loves it!
After making this fudge 400-gazillion times, I’m pretty sure I have the perfect recipe for success.
To get the perfect creamy texture, you’ll need a candy or instant read thermometer. For years I used the ‘soft ball stage’ test to check If the mixture was cooked enough. That old-school method can be a little more tedious than using a thermometer, and the results a little less consistent and dependable. Pick up an inexpensive thermometer and take the guess work out of candy making ๐
TIPS for making the BEST Peanut Butter Fudge:
- Use an instant read thermometer (like the one featured below) or a regular candy thermometer. Boil the sugar mixture to 240F then remove from the heat. This is a little higher temperature than you might cook regular fudge, but it’s necessary as we add creamy peanut butter to the mix. You want the fudge to be creamy and soft, but not squishy.
- In the video I was cooking on an induction hot plate which I turned off once the mixture reached 240F. This kind of cooktop cools quickly but normally I remove the pan from the heat when using my regular stove top.
- Be sure to have all your ingredients measured out and ready to go as this recipe moves fast once the butter sugar mixture reached 240F.
- Vary your craft by sprinkling light salted peanuts on top of the hot fudge, or stir in 1 cup of peanuts just before pouring into the prepared pan for a chunky fudge experience.
- For the chocolate peanut butter lovers among us, divide the mixture between two 8-inch or 9-inch baking pans. Next, make a batch of chocolate Easy Fantasy Fudgeย ย (skip the pecans)ย and divide between the two pans of peanut butter fudge. Instant layered fudge – and the best of both worlds!
- Use regular creamy peanut butter like Jiff or Peter Pan. Natural peanut butters don’t work well in this recipe.
- It may sound weird but I prefer using margarine instead of butter for this recipe. I never bake with margarine anymore, but for fudge and our English Toffee it just works best. If you can find it, Parkay is my favorite brand of margarine for candy making.
- This recipe is easily doubled then poured into a 9×13-inch baking pan.
- For shipping or gifting leave the fudge in one large piece, or several bigger pieces tightly wrapped in plastic wrap and a ziplock bag. The lucky recipient can slice when ready to serve and there’s less chance for the fudge to dry out. This also helps with longer storage of the fudge at home.
Can you freeze fudge?
Yes you can freeze fudge! Wrap tightly in plastic wrap, seal in a ziplock bag and store in an airtight container for up to a month. For longer shipping times, freeze before mailing.
Thanks for PINNING!
Peanut Butter Fudge
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 20 minutes
Total Time: 30 minutes
Yield: 64
Course: Candy, Dessert
Our most requested holiday treat - year after year!
Ingredients
- 12 tablespoons unsalted butter or margarine
- 2 ยฝ cups granulated sugar (556g)
- 5 ounces evaporated milk (about โ cup)
- โ cup creamy peanut butter (like Jif or Peter Pan)
- 12 ounces peanut butter chips (like Reese's)
- 7 ounce jar Marshmallow Creme (like Jet-Puffed)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 cup roasted, salted peanuts chopped (optional) for topping
Instructions
- Lightly butter an 8 or 9-inch square baking pan or line with parchment paper. Set aside.
- Combine the butter, sugar and milk in a heavy 3-quart saucepan. Bring to a full rolling boil on medium heat, stirring constantly.
- Continue cooking and stirring for 5 minutes on medium heat or until a candy thermometer reaches 240ยฐF (a little more than soft ball stage).
- Remove from the heat and stir in the peanut butter. Add the peanut butter chips and continue stirring until melted and smooth.
- Add the marshmallow cream and vanilla. Stir until smooth and blended.
- Immediately pour the fudge into prepared pan. Top with chopped peanuts (if using). Press the peanuts lightly into the fudge to adhere. Cool completely.
- Once cool cut into squares and store in an airtight container between layers of wax or parchment paper.
Recipe Notes
- Do not substitute sweetened condensed milk for the evaporated milk.
- Fudge can be frozen for up to 3 months.
- See TIPS in the original post for more ideas and tips for success.
Nutrition
Calories: 60kcal | Carbohydrates: 8g | Protein: 0.5g | Fat: 3g | Saturated Fat: 2g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 0.3g | Monounsaturated Fat: 1g | Trans Fat: 0.1g | Cholesterol: 6mg | Sodium: 8mg | Potassium: 15mg | Fiber: 0.1g | Sugar: 8g | Vitamin A: 71IU | Vitamin C: 0.04mg | Calcium: 7mg | Iron: 0.03mg
Here are a few more recipes you might also enjoy:
Burnt Sugar Almonds
English Toffee
Thanks so much for stopping by! Tricia
Originally posted December 2010, updated November 2018
Donna C Workman
What can I use in place of margarine
Tricia Buice
Unsalted butter is fine. I prefer this fudge with margarine because the oil content makes a difference. But if you don’t want to use margarine, butter should be fine.
Donna C Workman
I want to make this recipe it calls for margarine I’m out of it what can I substitute for it
Tricia Buice
Butter works fine to Donna. Good luck and thanks!
Boukri
Danke
Tricia Buice
Thank you!
Debbie Scanlon
I make a similar peanut butter fudge recipe but I use all brown sugar and just a cup of peanut butter, no chips. It tastes amazing! Itโs very soft though so I pour it into individual containers and give it as gifts with a small plastic spoon for eating. People always request more.
Tricia Buice
That sounds great Debbie – thanks for sharing your version. Love the idea of individual gifts with a spoon. Very thoughtful!
Martha
Can you send me your recipe with the brown sugar?! Thank you ?
Robin Cruickshank
I can’t seem to find a simple recipe with, “Sweetened Condensed. Milk?? Please. help!! Thanks, Robin, Athens, Georgia
Tricia Buice
I personally don’t have one but here’s a recipe you might like to try – https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/91737/eagle-brand-peanut-butter-fudge/ Good luck!
Laura
I have a slightly different version of this recipe that I have made for years and it is always a hit. No candy thermometer required. My adult son now makes it every year as it is his favorite.
Tricia Buice
Nice! Thanks for stopping by Laura. All the guys seem to love this fudge ๐
wanda duckworth
would love your recipe please
Tricia Buice
Hi Wanda – the recipe is in the post above where you left this comment. The printable recipe is shaded in light grey. Good luck!
Lisa Walker
First time msking Peanut Butter fudge. I’m excited
Tricia Buice
I’m excited for you to try this recipe! I hope you enjoy this delicious fudge. Thanks for giving it a try!
Janine
Hi, looks amazing! I want to make these but Iโm in the UK and canโt get a hold of peanut butter chips- if I replace with normal peanut butter, will it be too dry? Any suggestions? Thanks!
Tricia Buice
Hi Janine. So sorry you can’t get peanut butter chips. You may try white chocolate chips if you can get them. You need some sort of chocolate to help bind it together. Good luck and have a wonderful holiday season!
Marsha
I made some this morning and it is a little crumbly and dry. What did I do wrong. I thought I followed your recipe exactly. Any suggestions? Thanks.
Tricia Buice
Hi Marsha – so sorry it turned out dry. Did you use a thermometer? You can’t cook it past 240F or it will be too dry. Also, did you remove it from the heat after it reached soft ball stage? You have to stop the cooking pretty fast, add the peanut butter, chips, marshmallow creme, etc. before it has a chance to set up. Hope you’ll try again and I bet it is still delicious!
Marsha
I am absolutely going to try again. In fact I am getting ready to go get a thermometer because I didn’t use one! It was delicious, but not appropriate for gifts. Thanks for help.
Tricia Buice
Good luck Marsha – the thermometer will make all the difference ๐
Marsha
I purchased a thermometer and my fudge was perfect!! Now I am curious about the fantasy fudge recipe…you said you never use a thermometer when making it. Am I to understand that I should boil it for 5 minutes, check for a soft boil stage or should I try the thermometer with it also. Thanks again so very much!
Tricia Buice
Hey Marsha! That recipe was one of the first I ever posted on this blog – more than 8 years ago ๐ I didn’t have a thermometer back then, but of course I moved into the world of perfect fudge each and every time, with a thermometer. You’ll want to cook that chocolate fudge to a little lower temperature. Soft ball stage is 235F to 240F. I prefer the chocolate fudge somewhere in between – maybe 238F. I cook the peanut butter fudge to 240F because with the addition of peanut butter, it needs the extra cooking time. Hope that all makes sense but if not, please get in touch again. So glad it turned out for you!!!
John / Kitchen Riffs
Peanut butter fudge is the best! Mrs KR makes it in the microwave — doesn’t get as creamy as the traditional method for making it, however, which is a consideration. Peanut butter and chocolate also makes an excellent fudge. ๐ Anyway, this looks wonderful — super recipe. Great pictures, too. Thanks!
Tricia Buice
Thanks John! Welcome back ๐ Hope you had a fantastic trip!
Gerlinde
My husband would really like this fudge because he practically lives on peanut butter. Itโs a great idea for gifts.
Tricia Buice
Thanks Gerlinde – men really love this fudge, and I bet your husband would too!
Abbe@This is How I Cook
I think I have a few homes for this! What a winner! The FIL will be pleased!
Tricia Buice
Thanks Abbe! Hope you had a wonderful Thanksgiving ๐
Larry
Looks perfect Tricia. My tastes changed as I got older but this was my favorite as a kid.
Tricia Buice
Thanks Larry!
Jennifer @ Seasons and Suppers
I am long overdue for a fudge making session, so I can’t wait to try this one. Peanut butter is always a winner ๐
Tricia Buice
I’ve made this fudge so many times over the years, I think I could do it in my sleep! Hope you give it a try Jennifer – always delicious and a favorite on the dessert tray.
Susan
My hubby is a huge fan of peanut butter too ๐ They look melt-in-you-mouth delicious!
Tricia Buice
Thanks Susan!
Beverly Jones
This looks so creamy and tempting. I am thinking that for Christmas I could make two kinds of fudge: your Peanutbuuter and then adapt your wonderful recipe to Caramel Pecan Fudge. I’d use Ghirardelli Caramel Chips instead of the Peanutbutter Chips and Barney Almond Butter instead of the Peanutbutter. (Barney Butter is very creamy and homogenous as opposed to natural almond butter where the oil would separate.) I would add Toasted Pecans, like the Candied Pecans from Trader Joe’s.
I think there will be some happy grandhildren at our house ๐
Tricia Buice
Sounds terrific Beverly! Happy holiday baking and thanks for stopping by!
Bobbie Cox
It’s been a very long time since I enjoyed Peanut Butter Fudge. The mother of a friend in high school made it and, I’d make sure I went for a visit during Christmas when I knew Mrs Rallinson would make it. She only made the chocolate but, I’m eager to try to 2-tone. Thanks for posting this; I never thought I’d find it again. Do you have a recipe for DATE NUT BALLS? I think I’ve lost the copy my mother gave me and she died in 2002. I recall it uses dates, Rice Krispies, pecans and a sugary mix so you can roll them up into balls then roll in powdered sugar; no baking required. I asked my family which sweets they wanted me to make for Christmas and the DATE NUT BALLS was the only one they mentioned. Naturally, it’s the one recipe I can’t find! Thanks for your help!!
Tricia Buice
Thanks so much Bobbie. I don’t have a recipe for Date Nut Balls but found one on the Rice Krispy website. Maybe this is the one you’re looking for? Here’s a link – DATE NUT BALLS I lost a bunch of my mom’s recipes years ago in a recycling accident ๐ I was devastated. Happy holidays to you and thanks so very much for your comment. Enjoy!!
angiesrecipes
They look so tempting! Wish I could reach in and grab one to try :-))
Tricia Buice
I wish I could share it with you Angie – thanks so much!
Chris Scheuer
This looks creamy, decadent and totally irresistible!
Tricia Buice
Thanks Chris!
Jen
Peanut butter fudge is my FAVORITE too! My Nana (great-grandmother) use to make this. Please tell me if you can, why do so many people put marshmallow fluff (creme) in fudge now? What was wrong with the old fashioned way? <br /><br />Thank you for your time and consideration you have taken with your blog! Happy 4th of July!!
Sarah @ The Smart Kitchen
Peanut butter fudge is my FAVORITE!<br /><br />I used to make one that I put M&Ms in…this might be the closest to that recipe I have found.<br /><br />Bookmarking immediately.